The arrival of ChatGPT and other large language models sent a shiver through affiliate marketing. Headlines promised AI agents that would whisper the perfect product link into every shopper’s ear, making reviews and honest affiliates vanish. Scary thought, right? But the real story is far less dramatic.
Data now shows those predictions were premature. ChatGPT-driven referrals exist, sure, but they’re tiny and underpowered. They can summarize a product. They cannot honestly review one the way a human can.
Numbers you can’t ignore
Researchers digging into first‑party data from nearly a thousand e-commerce sites — sites that together make billions — found AI referrals are practically a rounding error. Organic LLM traffic makes up less than 0.2% of e-commerce sessions. Put differently: ChatGPT is about 200 times smaller than Google’s organic search as a traffic source.
And conversions? That’s where the myth really falls apart. Affiliate links are far more likely to turn a click into a sale — about 86% more likely than ChatGPT referrals. AI can drive clicks; it can’t reliably drive purchases. That’s the metric that matters for affiliates: not impressions, not word count, but conversion and revenue.
Why AI reviews rarely persuade
Trust. It’s the invisible bridge that makes affiliate marketing work. People click affiliate links because they trust the reviewer — someone who tried the product, felt its quirks, and told the truth, warts and all. Generative AI doesn’t have stories. It doesn’t get frustrated when a device freezes in the rain or glow at how a feature unexpectedly simplifies a workflow.
LLMs lack lived experience, which shows up as gaps in experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness. They write like they’ve seen everything, but they haven’t actually done anything. Readers pick up on that. When content smells like it was AI-made, trust drops — a lot. One study found readers’ trust falls nearly 50% when they suspect content was generated by AI, and that suspicion cuts purchase consideration by about 14%.
There’s also the problem of hallucinations — believable but wrong assertions. Or subtle failures to read tone and cultural nuance. These slip-ups erode credibility, and credibility is currency in affiliate marketing.
The human advantage
That doesn’t mean AI is useless. Far from it. It’s a tool. A helpful, time-saving tool that scales outlines, drafts, and research. But tools need craftsmen. When authors take an AI draft and humanize it — add testing notes, personal anecdotes, clear advice — the results jump. One set of comparisons showed AI-only articles averaged 23 visits, while AI-plus-human editing averaged over 100 visits.
Who wins in that setup? The reviewer and the curator. The reviewer tells you about the flap of a jacket hem in heavy wind. The curator frames whether that jacket matters to a commuter in New York or a hiker in the Rocky Mountains. That context, that specificity, converts.
So yes, AI can help create volume. It cannot replace the trust built by lived experience. For now, affiliates who lean into authentic testing, honest pros and cons, and audience-aligned judgment keep the conversion edge.
What affiliates should do next
Don’t panic. Use AI, but don’t outsource your credibility to it. Use LLMs to brainstorm, to draft, to check facts — then bring the content back into the real world with your voice. Test products when you can. Tell small, concrete stories. Say what worked and what didn’t. That kind of nuance is what turns skeptical readers into buyers.
And remember: traffic without intent is noise. Conversion comes from authority and trust. That’s human work.
Want to share your take? Leave a comment below with your experience using AI for product reviews — did it help or hurt your conversions? Follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest tomore practical affiliate strategies and real-world case studies.
Amazon Influencer vs. Amazon Associate: discover which program is right for you.
Sources
- www.searchengineland.com/llms-google-referral-conversion-study-463747
- www.affiversemedia.com/the-ai-traffic-lie-why-chatgpt-e-commerce-referrals-are-failing-to-live-up-to-the-hype/
- www.digiday.com/marketing/e-commerce-sites-see-low-sales-from-chatgpt-traffic-new-study-finds/
Hello folk,
I’m here to provide you with tips, tricks, and guidance on how to join affiliate programs and monetize your sites or social media accounts. On the right of the site, you can find a list of categories. Just click on those that interest you and see the affiliate programs available. Join those that fit with your writing expertise and your target audience. If you like my posts, please give me a like here:
Facebook, X (Twitter), Instagram, Pinterest, Website, Contact us